History
The pie grew out of the isolated Florida Keys before the Overseas Highway, when canned milk had to stand in for scarce fresh dairy. Families in Key West passed recipes back generations; the oldest documented example, published in 1939, was described as used by a Key West family for more than half a century. A later theory credited Borden's New York test kitchen, but Keys researchers have marshaled pre-1931 evidence against it, and Florida named the pie its official state pie in 2006.
Fun fact
Sweetened condensed milk once stood in for scarce fresh milk in this tart Keys custard pie.
Florida named it the official state pie in 2006, though true key limes left the islands decades ago.
Dish notes
- Local tradition
- Old Florida Keys fishing-camp dessert
- Main ingredients
- Key lime juice, Sweetened condensed milk
- Texture
- Silky
- How it's served
- Chilled
Ordering tip
Ask whether it's made with real key limes, and take it meringue- or cream-topped
Availability
On virtually every menu in the Florida Keys; authentic key limes are now grown elsewhere
What defines it
- key lime juice custard
- sweetened condensed milk base
- graham cracker crust with whipped cream or meringue






